Write Good Job Descriptions


Hey Reader,

I am back in your inbox this week!

So, I am not much into astrology. But I read online that Uranus is moving out of Taurus, where it has been parked for the past 7 years, and into Gemini where it will sit for the next 30 years or so. From what I read, this shift will give Taureans (those born under the Taurus zodiac sign) a break from the upheavals many of us have experienced since 2018-19.

I don’t know if I fully understand the implications or if I fully buy in, but I will gladly take a break from the disruption recent years have brought into my life and my business. 😭

Let me know if you feel the same. 🤝

Over on LinkedIn, I shared some thoughts about job descriptions that I wanted to share with you.

I believe a 4th career is brewing in my heart right now, so I have been reading job descriptions to gain some insights for my own journey. Yesterday, I was reading a job description for what appeared to be a senior role in an industry that I am familiar with and I want to share some best practices with you.

👉For years, I have put together job descriptions to attract the right candidates. Book a strategy call with me if you'd like some help with streamlining your hiring process.

Getting it Right the First Time

Creating a job description that attracts the right candidate for the role you are hiring for is part art, part expertise, and part system. Most leaders I work with are juggling multiple obligations, so getting a hire right the first time is critical. I find that organizations approach job descriptions in different ways. Most hiring managers inherit the format they use because it takes significant effort to standardize these documents, especially in large organizations. Building out a template is always worth it in the long run, but it takes time when the work from the vacant role(s) is piling up.

Check out this graphic from a good article from ADP for putting together job descriptions.

Common Job Description Missteps

Always remember the goal of a hiring process is to fill a role with the right candidate who will stay with your organization over time. No one wants to hire for the same role over and over.

Here are four missteps based on the job descriptions I have read lately.

  1. Length. Most job descriptions are too long. Yesterday, I printed a 6-page job description. Single-spaced. I counted 24 bullets. It is easy to get lost in job descriptions that are too long. In this scenario, the salary will always be too small when the responsibilities feel endless.
    ​
  2. Conflicting responsibilities. In the job description I read yesterday, the core responsibilities lacked cohesion. That signals role confusion, which can be attributed to a lack of clarity in the role. Or it could be that the job description was written using a combination of AI with some human tweaks, which made it confusing.
    ​
  3. Experience mismatch. Based on the job title, the role sought someone with experience. Reading it more closely, I realized nope. This job is a junior role with a big title. I can foresee mismatches in the candidate pool. In this instance, the title attracts highly experienced candidates who will get bored with the day-to-day because the role does not require as much leadership as the job description suggests.
    ​
  4. Core competencies. Be clear about how core competencies connect back to individual performance reviews. When it's performance review time, competencies outlined in the job description should link back to this process. This is a place where templates are critical, especially in large organizations.

If you have roles to fill, craft the most accurate job description you can. A good job description is clear, concise, and always includes the salary. If you need help creating a template, also reach out. I like helping people streamline their proceses to make them more efficient and more equitable.

Looking ahead, I am reading an interesting paper on the role of AI in nonprofit organizations. I’ll share it with you next week.

Until next time,
Joanna


P.S. If my newsletter has made you smile, helped you think about something differently, or just been a bright spot in your inbox, consider buying me a cup of coffee.​ It helps me keep creating, covering coffee costs, late-night edits, and everything in between. Thanks for reading and being part of this journey with me!

Dr. Joanna Shoffner Scott

Race in the Workplace is newsletter to help you get equitable results in changing times. It is published weekly for leaders of organizations and teams. Each newsletter includes actionable tools, practical guidance, and best practices for leaders who believe that equity still matters.

Read more from Dr. Joanna Shoffner Scott

Hey Reader, As always, I hope each week brings more justice, creativity, and white space to your calendar. In case you missed it: I am continuing my Lessons Learned series, where I share lessons and takeaways from my clients after 10 years in business. I'm sharing 10 lessons over the next few weeks. Click here for last week’s lesson. As I reflect on this week’s newsletter, I want to share a case study that I wrote about some work I did with a communications team. The team wanted to build a...

Hey Reader, I hope this week brought more joy, creativity, and white space to your calendar. As I reflect on 10 years in business, I remember setting up my systems. I worked with a project manager to help me create project timelines in ClickUp, the tool we were using at the time. I put together a list of tasks by project. After receiving the list, she messaged me asking for a call. Me: What questions do you have about the list? Her: Where are the deadlines? Me: Huh? Partners should just work...

Sign post with 2 options that read decision A and decision b

Hey Reader, As always, I hope this week brought more joy, creativity, and white space to your calendar. This was a big week in the Scott house as my "not-so-little-anymore" daughter started high school. Y'all, I am a mom to a high school freshman!! It feels like just yesterday I was holding her little hand and walking her into her first preschool class. This week, I dropped her off in carpool and watched from a distance as she walked into her new high school. I felt all the feels this week....