Every leader faces 2 decision-making challenges


Hey Reader,

As always, I hope this week brought more joy, creativity, and white space to your calendar.

This was a big week in the Scott house as my "not-so-little-anymore" daughter started high school.

Y'all, I am a mom to a high school freshman!!

It feels like just yesterday I was holding her little hand and walking her into her first preschool class. This week, I dropped her off in carpool and watched from a distance as she walked into her new high school.

I felt all the feels this week. All of them.

Before I dive into this week’s newsletter, I want to let you know I am taking on clients for new projects starting this quarter. I can take on three new projects. If you haven’t already, check out my updated services. I currently offer strategic visioning and planning, organizational assessments, policy and practice reviews, coaching, and meeting facilitation. Or, we can design a custom project to address something specific in your organization.

While I am leaning into writing more, I can’t do it without consulting work. So, reach out with projects where consulting support can help you move forward.


Lessons In Leadership Series

I am continuing my Lessons Learned series, where I share lessons I have learned and takeaways from my clients after 10 years in business. I'll share 10 lessons over the next few weeks. To recap, in last week’s newsletter, I kicked off the series with the first lesson about “Switching it Up” to encourage you to give yourself permission to lead and build differently according to what works for you and your team, not what works for someone else.

This week, I want to share Lesson #2: Decision-making can challenge every leader. For context, over the years, I have worked with different types of organizations, from tiny nonprofits to large foundations to government agencies. Despite differences in type, size, and resources, every leader faces the same challenge: how to handle decision-making.

Every executive leads differently. Some lead in hierarchical, top-down ways. Others are more democratic, using staff buy-in models. Yet, others make big decisions in groups, either in a pair (e.g., Executive Director and a Deputy) or with a leadership team.

No matter the style, I have seen two core challenges most often through the years.

  1. Documenting decisions once made
  2. Assigning clear decision rights

Few leaders document their decisions.
​

The first is that most leaders do not document their decisions. So, if a manager misses an important budget discussion that resulted in a decision, how will it be communicated back? This scenario raises other questions like:

What if the decision negatively impacts my team?

Where does that decision live once it's been made?

Not having ready answers to these questions has prompted many a manager to either call into the meeting or drag themselves (sick and all) into the office. I raise this example because it seems small, but it's really not. Many managers feel pressure to be in every meeting. If they're not, they'll miss something important because there aren't established processes to document decisions. That pressure to always be present is where the inequity comes in. The pressure also leads to burnout.
​

Clear decision rights improve cross-team collaboration.
​

The second area of decision-making where I have seen leaders struggle most is assigning decision rights in implementation. So, after a decision is made, who can make adjustments, and when? I think accountability is the most delicate at this stage of decision-making. By that, I mean how team members hold themselves responsible for their role in implementing the decision (even one they don’t agree with) while honoring the integrity of the process. In short, the ways your team holds responsibility.

Most challenges with decision rights stem from trust gaps, asymmetrical access to information, and unclear roles. When these challenges happen at the same time in a leadership team, the result is usually that every director is involved in every decision and has to attend every meeting. That's a surefire way to spot the problem. Additionally, project management frameworks like MOCHA or RACI don’t work in teams with this kind of decision-making dynamic.

I wish I could share an easy 1-2-3 solution. There isn’t one.

This leadership challenge isn't just about a technical process. It’s adaptive. Because it’s an adaptive challenge, leaders and their teams have to name it and sort it out together.

In next week’s newsletter, I’ll share Lesson #3 in the series: accountability. If you like the series, or if you have a specific question or challenge, share it with me.

​
Until next time,
Joanna

P.S. If my newsletter has made you smile, helped you think about something differently, or just been a bright spot in your inbox, consider buying me a cup of coffee.​ It helps me keep creating, covering coffee costs, late-night edits, and everything in between. Thanks for reading and being part of this journey with me!

Dr. Joanna Shoffner Scott

Race in the Workplace is newsletter to help you get equitable results in changing times. It is published weekly for leaders of organizations and teams. Each newsletter includes actionable tools, practical guidance, and best practices for leaders who believe that equity still matters.

Read more from Dr. Joanna Shoffner Scott

Hey Reader, As always, I hope each week brings more justice, creativity, and white space to your calendar. In case you missed it: I am continuing my Lessons Learned series, where I share lessons and takeaways from my clients after 10 years in business. I'm sharing 10 lessons over the next few weeks. Click here for last week’s lesson. As I reflect on this week’s newsletter, I want to share a case study that I wrote about some work I did with a communications team. The team wanted to build a...

Hey Reader, I hope this week brought more joy, creativity, and white space to your calendar. As I reflect on 10 years in business, I remember setting up my systems. I worked with a project manager to help me create project timelines in ClickUp, the tool we were using at the time. I put together a list of tasks by project. After receiving the list, she messaged me asking for a call. Me: What questions do you have about the list? Her: Where are the deadlines? Me: Huh? Partners should just work...

Hey Reader, As always, I hope each week brings more joy, justice, and white space to your calendar. I want to share three things with you this week. My “Lesson Learned” series The importance of giving yourself permission to switch it up An essay called Who Funds Equity When You Can No Longer Say the Word? As I mentioned in last week’s newsletter, this month marks my 10th year in business as the founder of Stamey Street Consulting Group. This milestone has sparked a lot of reflection about my...